"We are in love with the thing that will ruin us."
In the 4th century BC, Alexander the Great was the most powerful man on earth. He had conquered Greece, Egypt, and the Persian Empire. He traveled with an army, servants, and mountains of gold. He was the "Sovereign" of the known world.
While in Corinth, he heard about a philosopher named Diogenes who lived in a barrel and owned nothing but a cloak and a staff. Curious, Alexander decided to visit him. He found Diogenes sunbathing. Alexander stood over him, casting a shadow, and said, "I am Alexander the Great. Ask for any favor you choose, and I will grant it."
It was a blank check from the King of Kings. Diogenes could have asked for a palace, a governorship, or a chest of gold. Diogenes squinted up at him and said, "Yes. Stand out of my sunlight."
Alexander was stunned. His soldiers laughed, thinking Diogenes was a fool. But Alexander silenced them. As they walked away, he famously said, "If I were not Alexander, I would wish to be Diogenes."
Alexander recognized the truth. He was the master of the world, but he was a slave to his ambition. He had to keep conquering to feed his ego. He had to manage generals, suppress rebellions, and worry about assassins.
Diogenes was the master of himself. He didn't need a palace to be happy, he just needed the sun. Because he wanted nothing, Alexander had no power over him. You can't bribe a man who desires nothing, and you can't threaten a man who fears nothing.
Seneca writes that we are often "in love with the thing that will ruin us." We chase the promotion, the big house, or the fame. We think these things make us powerful. But often, they just pile up anxieties. The big house requires a mortgage that keeps you trapped in a job you hate. The fame requires constant performance. We fall in love with our own chains because they are made of gold.
True sovereignty isn't having the most. It's needing the least.
Errors & Corrections
- Don't mistake expensive chains for freedom. You might envy the CEO with the private jet. But if he has to answer emails at 3 AM and can't see his kids, he isn't free. He's just a well-paid servant to the shareholders.
- Don't confuse standard of living with quality of life. You can upgrade your standard of living (car, house) while downgrading your quality of life (stress, no time). The "thing that ruins us" often looks like an upgrade.
- Don't try to fill an internal hole with external things. Alexander was trying to fill a void in his soul by swallowing the map. It didn't work. You can't fix insecurity with accumulation.
Applications to Modern Life
Work
We often fall for the trap of the "Golden Handcuffs." You get the promotion and the raise, but now you have to work weekends and carry the stress home. You're in love with the status, but the status is ruining your health and your family life. The Stoic worker asks the cost of the "sunlight" before accepting the gold. Sometimes the lower-paying job with more autonomy is the richer position.
Leadership
A leader driven by ego is like Alexander. They need constant expansion and validation. This often ruins the culture and burns out the team. A leader like Diogenes (in spirit) serves the mission, not the mirror. They don't need the corner office to feel important. They just need the team to succeed.
Athleticism & Sport
An athlete can become obsessed with the stats or the record book. They play for the "thing that ruins them" which is the obsession with legacy. They stop enjoying the game. They play tight and anxious. The athlete who plays for the love of the sport, regardless of the record, retains their joy and often performs better because they're loose.
Politics
Politicians spend half their time fundraising to keep the seat they fought so hard to get. The office becomes the master. They compromise their values to stay in power. They're in love with the title, even as the title ruins their integrity. A true public servant is willing to lose the election to save their soul.
Social Media
We say we want "followers," but followers are a burden. You have to feed them content. You have to worry about losing them. You have to curate your life to please them. We fall in love with the influencer lifestyle, not realizing it turns us into digital serfs working for an algorithm.
Interpersonal Relationships
We sometimes chase the "trophy" partner, someone who looks great on paper or on Instagram. We love the image. But if that person is toxic or incompatible, we're in love with the thing that will ruin our peace. Choose the partner who lets you sit in the sun, not the one who casts a shadow.
Maxims
- He who needs nothing commands everything.
- Don't buy a master and call it success.
- Stand out of my sunlight.
In-depth Concepts
Autarkeia (Self-Sufficiency)
The Cynics and Stoics prized Autarkeia. It's the state of being self-sufficient, needing very little from the outside world to maintain tranquility. Diogenes is the ultimate model of this. The more you need from the world, the more leverage the world has on you.
Tyranny of Fortune
Seneca warns against subjecting ourselves to the "Tyranny of Fortune." When we attach our happiness to things that Fortune controls (money, power), we make Fortune our Queen. We're only happy when she's in a good mood. The Stoic deposes the Queen and rules themself.