calendar_todayJanuary 30schedule4 min readauto_awesomeDisciplinebookmarkThe Dichotomy of Control

"For it is not death or pain that is to be feared, but the fear of pain or death."

In May 1995, Christopher Reeve was the definition of physical perfection. He was 6'4", athletic, and handsome. To the world, he was literally Superman, having played the Man of Steel in four movies.

Then, in a split second, physics took over. During an equestrian competition in Virginia, his horse refused a jump. Reeve was thrown forward and landed on his head. The impact shattered his first and second vertebrae.

He woke up paralyzed from the neck down. He couldn't move his arms. He couldn't move his legs. He couldn't even breathe without a machine. The irony was brutal. The strongest man in cinema was now trapped in a motionless body.

In the hospital, Reeve was terrified. He saw his life as over. He told his wife, Dana, that maybe they should "let him go." He was gripped by the fear of a life with pain and disability.

Dana looked him in the eye and said, "You're still you. And I love you." That was the switch. Reeve realized that "Superman" (the body) was gone, but Christopher (the mind) was still there. He stopped fearing the condition and started managing it. He became a director, an author, and the world's leading activist for spinal cord research.

He famously said, "I refuse to allow a disability to determine how I live my life. I don't mean to be reckless, but setting a goal that seems a bit daunting actually is very helpful toward recovery."

Epictetus argues that the thing itself, whether paralysis, sickness, or the prospect of death, isn't the problem. These are natural events. They happen to everyone eventually. The problem is the opinion we hold about them.

If you judge paralysis to be "evil," you'll be miserable. If you judge it to be "a difficult indifferent," you can bear it with dignity. Reeve proved that you can lose the body entirely and still keep the man. The ultimate test isn't what happens to you. It's whether you let the fear of what happens dictate your reality.

Errors & Corrections

  • Don't die before you're dead. We spend decades worrying about death. We die a thousand times in our imagination. When death finally comes, it only happens once. The fear costs more than the event.
  • Don't confuse the vehicle with the driver. You drive a car. If the car breaks down, you get out. You don't think you are broken. Your body is just the biological car. If it breaks, the driver (the mind) is still intact.
  • Don't leverage your fear. We often use fear to motivate ourselves. "If I don't work hard, I'll be homeless." This is dirty fuel. It burns out the engine. Use purpose instead. "I work hard because I love the craft."

Applications to Modern Life

Work

You're terrified of public speaking. The fear makes your hands shake and your voice crack. But what's the actual event? You're standing in a room talking. That's it. It's not a lion attack. It's not a fire. It's just words. Separate the event (talking) from the fear (judgment of failure), and the task becomes manageable.

Leadership

A leader afraid of conflict becomes a "nice" boss who ruins the company. They let bad behavior slide because they fear the awkward conversation. A Stoic leader realizes that the conversation is just a conversation. It might be tense, but it won't kill you. The fear of the conflict is doing more damage than the conflict ever could.

Athleticism & Sport

The gymnast fears the beam. The fear makes them tight, which makes them fall. The "Ultimate Test" for the athlete is to respect the danger without fearing it. You acknowledge the risk of injury, prepare for it, and then put it out of your mind so you can flow.

Politics

Terrorism works because it weaponizes the "fear of death." The actual statistical risk of dying in a terror attack is near zero. But the fear changes laws, starts wars, and curtails liberties. A Stoic citizenry looks at the math, refuses to be terrified, and lives freely despite the risks.

Social Media

We have a "fear of death" regarding our digital identities. We're terrified of being "cancelled" or ignored. We act as if a mean comment is a physical wound. It isn't. It's pixels on a screen. Turn it off, and the "pain" vanishes.

Interpersonal Relationships

We stay in bad relationships because we fear being alone. We think loneliness is a form of death. It's not. It's just solitude. By fearing the solitude, we choose the misery of a toxic partner. Face the fear. Being alone is better than being with someone who makes you feel alone.

Maxims

  • Fear is the enemy, not the event.
  • I'm the driver, not the car.
  • Superman is a state of mind.

In-depth Concepts

Dogma (Judgment/Opinion)

Epictetus uses the word Dogma to describe our judgments. The event (paralysis) is neutral. The judgment ("This is terrible") creates the suffering. If you change the Dogma, you change the emotion.

Tarache (Disturbance)

This is the mental agitation caused by fear. It disrupts the smooth flow of life (Euroia). The Stoic goal is to remove the Tarache by realizing that the things we fear are usually outside our control and therefore shouldn't disturb our inner peace.