calendar_todayJanuary 13schedule5 min readauto_awesomeDisciplinebookmarkThe Dichotomy of Control

"Look down from above on the countless herds of men and their countless solemnities..."

schedule5 min readMarcus Aurelius

On February 14, 1990, the Voyager 1 spacecraft was leaving our solar system. It was nearly 4 billion miles away. At the request of astronomer Carl Sagan, NASA commanded the probe to turn its camera around and take one last series of photos of Earth.

The result was an image of a vast, dark emptiness with a tiny, faint speck of light suspended in a sunbeam. That speck was Earth. It occupied no more than a single pixel.

Sagan famously wrote about this image in his book Pale Blue Dot. He said, "Look again at that dot. That's here. That's home. That's us. On it everyone you love, everyone you know, everyone you ever heard of, every human being who ever was, lived out their lives."

He pointed out the absurdity of our conflicts when viewed from this distance. "Think of the rivers of blood spilled by all those generals and emperors so that, in glory and triumph, they could become the momentary masters of a fraction of a dot."

Sagan was performing a spiritual exercise that the Stoics invented two thousand years earlier. Marcus Aurelius frequently practiced the "View from Above." He would close his eyes and imagine himself rising above the earth. He looked down on the armies, the farms, the marriages, and the funerals.

From the ground, a border dispute looks like the most important thing in the world. From the sky, the border is invisible. From the ground, your bad day feels like a tragedy. From the sky, it's a micro-second in the history of a single species on a small rock.

This perspective doesn't make life meaningless. It makes our anxieties meaningless. It strips away the ego and the self-importance that cause us so much suffering. When you realize you're living on a "mote of dust suspended in a sunbeam," it becomes very hard to take your traffic jam seriously.

Errors & Corrections

  • Don't mistake size for value. Just because we're small doesn't mean we're worthless. A diamond is small, but it has value. We're the only part of the known universe that can think and love. That makes us precious, even if we're physically tiny.
  • Don't use nihilism as an excuse. Some people look at the stars and say, "Nothing matters, so I can do whatever I want." That's lazy. The Stoic looks at the stars and says, "My ego doesn't matter, so I will serve the whole."
  • Don't stay in the clouds. You have to come back down. The View from Above is a medicine you take to calm down, not a place to live. You still have to do the dishes and pay your taxes.

Applications to Modern Life

Work

You're stressed about a deadline or a quarterly report. Your heart is racing. Pause and zoom out. Will this report matter in five years? Will it matter in 500 years? Probably not. Do the work because it's your duty today, but release the crushing weight of significance. It's just a small task on a small planet.

Leadership

Leaders often become tyrants because they build "little empires." They obsess over titles and office size. A leader with the cosmic perspective remains humble. They know they're just a steward for a brief moment in time. They serve the mission rather than trying to build a monument to themselves.

Athleticism & Sport

The pressure of the championship game can be paralyzing. The athlete thinks, "The whole world is watching." The Stoic athlete zooms out. It's a game played with a ball on a Tuesday. The sun will rise tomorrow regardless of the score. This detachment loosens the muscles and allows for peak performance.

Politics

Nationalism relies on the illusion that our patch of dirt is the center of the universe. The View from Above dissolves this. It shows one interconnected biosphere. It reminds us that pollution and viruses do not respect the lines we draw on maps. A Stoic citizen votes and acts with the health of the whole "dot" in mind.

Social Media

We get dopamine from likes and anxiety from trolls. We treat our digital reputation as if it were real life. But the internet is just electricity. In a thousand years, all the servers will be rust. Your follower count is the most fragile thing on earth. Build your character instead.

Interpersonal Relationships

You're fighting with your spouse about how to load the dishwasher. You're furious. Zoom out. You're two biological organisms with a very short expiration date, clinging to each other on a rock hurtling through space. Is this really how you want to spend your limited time? The cosmic view creates immediate forgiveness.

Maxims

  • You're a pixel; act accordingly.
  • The earth is a single point.
  • Momentary masters of a fraction of a dot.

In-depth Concepts

Kataskopos (The Watcher/Overview)

Marcus often adopts the persona of the Kataskopos, or the one who looks down from a height. This isn't just about space, it's about time. Viewing the present moment from the perspective of deep time (millions of years) creates the same shrinking effect on our troubles.

Sympatheia (Cosmic Connection)

The View from Above isn't meant to make you feel lonely. It's meant to trigger Sympatheia, the realization that all things are mutually woven together. When you see the Earth as one unit, you understand that hurting your neighbor is hurting your own ship.