"If you consider only what is yours to be yours, and view what belongs to others as truly belonging to others, no one will ever compel you."
Epictetus wasn't always a famous philosopher. He was born a slave. His name literally means "acquired" or "gained." He spent his youth serving Epaphroditus, a wealthy secretary to the Emperor Nero.
According to the famous story, one day his master became angry and started twisting Epictetus's leg. Epictetus didn't scream. He didn't beg. He simply looked at his master and said calmly, "If you keep doing that, you will break it."
The master continued twisting until the bone snapped. Epictetus didn't rage. He looked at his broken leg and said, "I told you that you would break it."
For the rest of his life, Epictetus walked with a limp. But that limp was a reminder of his greatest victory. In that moment of torture, the master had control over the leg, but he had zero control over Epictetus. The master was a slave to his anger. Epictetus was free because he didn't mistake his leg for "his own."
He understood that his body belonged to his master. But his will, his reason, and his character belonged exclusively to him. By surrendering the leg, he kept his soul intact.
Epictetus teaches that suffering comes from a case of mistaken identity. We think we own our bodies, our houses, our children, and our jobs. We don't. These are all on loan from the universe. They can be recalled at any moment.
If you think these things are yours, you will be terrified of the thief who can take them. You will be a slave to anyone who has power over them. But if you realize that the only thing you truly own is your own reasoned choice, then no thief can touch you. You become invincible.
Errors & Corrections
- Don't confuse possession with ownership. You might possess a house or a job today, but you don't own it. The bank, the fire, or the boss can take it back. Enjoy it while you have it, but hold it loosely.
- Don't hate the thief. If someone steals your car, they've only taken a piece of metal. If you hate them, you're letting them steal your peace of mind too. Now they have taken two things.
- Don't negotiate your freedom. We often trade our peace of mind for money or status. We think we're "winning," but we're actually selling the only thing that is truly ours to buy things that can never be ours.
Applications to Modern Life
Work
You might worry constantly about being fired. This fear makes you timid and compliant. You become a "slave" to the employer because you think the job is yours. It isn't. The job is an agreement that can end today. If you accept that the job isn't yours, you lose the fear. You can work with boldness and honesty because you aren't trying to protect a possession. You're simply performing a role.
Leadership
A micromanaging leader thinks they own the team's output. They hover and control because they attach their ego to the result. This stifles the team. The Stoic leader realizes they don't own the team's mind. They own their own instructions and their own culture. By releasing the need to control every keystroke, they actually gain more influence.
Athleticism & Sport
An athlete often thinks their body is their property. When an injury happens, they feel robbed. They get depressed. But the body was never yours. It was a loan from nature with a high interest rate. When the bill comes due in the form of injury or age, pay it without complaint. Focus on what you still own which is your tactical mind and your love for the game.
Politics
We act as if we own the country or the culture. When the "other side" wins, we feel like something was stolen from us. But the country is a collective entity. It shifts and changes. You don't own the election result. You own your vote and your voice. Focus on those, and you remain a free citizen regardless of who sits in the White House.
Social Media
You build a following on a platform. You think, "These are my followers." Then the algorithm changes or your account gets banned. You feel devastated. You forgot the rule. The account belongs to the company. The audience belongs to themselves. Only your content belongs to you. If you build your house on rented land, don't be surprised when the landlord changes the locks.
Interpersonal Relationships
Jealousy is the belief that you own another person. You check their phone or control who they see because you're afraid of losing "your" person. But people are not property. They're free agents. If you try to compel them to stay, you destroy the relationship. You can only own your own capacity to be a good partner.
Maxims
- The leg is the master's; the will is mine.
- If it can be taken, it wasn't yours.
- Only the reasoned choice is my own.
In-depth Concepts
Prohairesis (Moral Character/Will)
This is the central concept in Epictetus's philosophy. Prohairesis is the faculty of choice. It's the part of us that assents or dissents to impressions. It's the only thing that is truly free because no one can force your Prohairesis to choose something it doesn't want to choose.
Eleutheria (Freedom)
For the Stoics, Eleutheria wasn't a political status. It was a mental state. A person could be a prisoner and possess Eleutheria if they feared nothing. A King could be a slave if he feared losing his throne. Freedom is the absence of fear regarding external things.